Essays academic service

A comparison of a midsummer nights dream and romeo and juliet written by william shakespeare

Would you like to merge this question into it? MERGE already exists as an alternate of this question. Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it? MERGE exists and is an alternate of. There is an odd parallelism between the two plays, which were written at about the same time and have many similarities in style, especially a lot of rhymed couplets.

Romeo and Juliet is a tragedy, Dream is a comedy. Juliet's predicament of being ordered to marry a man when she loves another is also Hermia's.

Juliet's solution is the tragic one; Hermia's is comic. Shakespeare doesn't often talk about fairies, but they are a big part of Dream and, son of a gun, there they are in a big long speech by Mercutio. Day and night symbolism is most important in both plays. In Dream, reality is like the moon, the inconstant moon that nightly changes.

Whatever is real, even the love of lovers for each other, can be changed by the fairies. A figurative jackass can become a literal one. The lovers are star-crossed, and those stars are not going to change, nor is there anything that they can do to change what is and what will be. The love of the lovers, far from being as fickle as the moon, will last forever, even into death.


It is supposedly set in Athens, the city in Greece. This is presumably because Theseus is a legendary character in the history of that city. However, nobody behaves like ancie…nt Greeks, and Theseus's title "Duke" is decidedly not Greek at all.

Neither are the names of the "rude mechanicals" which are totally English, or the fairies, who come from English and European mythology. We might consider this to be an Athens of the imagination, an Athens imagined by someone who didn't know very much about the place. Directly after is what historians are guessing. They were written at almost the same time.

Would you like that answer in essay form by any chance? What is the comparison between Hermia and Helena in A Midsummer nights dream? Physically, Helena is tall and blonde and Hermia is short and dark. Hermia is optimistic and upbeat. She has confidence in Lysander and his love for her. She has …a difficult time being persuaded that Lysander is more interested in Helena than in her.

Once this sinks in, her reaction is to get mad at Helena for taking him away. Helena, on the other hand, has no self-esteem at all. She invites Demetrius to beat her and treat her like a dog "I am your spaniel".

When Lysander and Demetrius say they love her she will not believe them, because she cannot believe that anyone could love her. The contrast between bouncy, confident Hermia and whiny, self-effacing Helena couldn't be greater. I'd honestly say that there isn't much difference between them. Some Shakespeare analysts look at a Midsummer Night's Dream as an example of a story with no psychologically realistic characters. The idea that characters need to act like real people is more of 20th century notion.

A comparison of a midsummer nights dream and romeo and juliet written by william shakespeare

In other words, a Midsummer Night's Dream is more focused on Shakespeare's ideas of dreams vs. The fact is, Hermia and Helena, Lysander and Demetrius, they're not all that different from each other! Apart from their names and who they like in the beginning, we could not tell them apart from their speech or dialogue. They have no personality or will power of their own, which is why they are almost always controlled by the love potion that puck sprinkles in their eyes. In the first act, Helena is the jealous one because both men love Hermia.

Later on, not sure if it's the second act or not Hermia is the jealous one, suggesting that the only thing that separates her from her sisterly double, Helena, is the fact that she was not in Helena's shoes. Lysander loved her so she didn't act jealous.

But the moment the two men switched to Helena, she acted the same way. This shows that they are kind of the same person.

That's just one way of looking it but I'm sure you could find critics who disagree.

  • Love and madmen are closely aligned in this play;
  • This can be evidenced in MSND by Puck and Oberon who watch over the young lovers to save them from coming to any harm;
  • The fairies are a symbol of eroticism and imagination.

Thomas Fisher in 1600 2nd: William Jaggard in 1619 3rd: John Heminges and Henry Condell in 1623 Loads of people since then. The l…ovely Thisbe whom Bottom cannot help calling Thisne for some reason is played by the only very slightly bearded bellows-mender Flute. At the casting session Flute is told he "may play it in a mask", but this like just about everything else in the play may well change before the performances.

For a hilarious and broad in more than one sense Thisbe, see Joe E Brown in the 1935 movie.

  1. The idea that characters need to act like real people is more of 20th century notion. Ripped from the pages of a midsummer's night dream with a midsummer night's dream written for the spook-me romeo and juliet - william shakespeare,.
  2. Thomas Fisher in 1600 2nd. Shakespeare wrote a midsummer's night dream and romeo and juliet during the same time period his treatment of love, however, is strikingly different lysander says, the course of love never did run smooth compare and contrast the relationships of hermia and lysander with that of juliet and.
  3. Showing a similarity of ideas about love. This can be seen in MSND with Hermia running away to the woods to be with Lysander, avoiding the marriage to Demetrius that her father desires for her.
  4. In Romeo and Juliet love is presented in an entirely different manner, the love between the couple the audience can feel from the stage.

For a touching and seriously amazing Thisbe, see Sam Rockwell in the 1999 movie. Both plays are written with much of the dialogue in rhyming couplets, an unusual feature. There is also relatively little prose. Both plays have to do with young couples whose… plans to marry are opposed by an older generation Egeus opposes Hermia and Lysander's marriage plans; we assume that the feuding Montagues and Capulets would not agree to Romeo and Juliet's union and by the state Romeo is banished; Hermia is commanded to marry Demetrius or become a nun.

The tragic end of Romeo and Juliet is very similar to the end of the story of Pyramus and Thisbe which becomes a comic play in A Midsummer Night's Dream. The fairies and their world are reflected in the long speech by Mercutio about Queen Mab equals Titaniaher fairies and her effect on dreams. Both plays fall into the category of Shakespearean plays which have recurring theme words. These are similar especially if contrasted with "blood" in Macbeth or "honesty" in Othello. In both plays there is a similar symbolism of night and day.

The problems arise in the day, but relief is found in the night--in Dream, Theseus's court judges Hermia's case in the day, but the fairies resolve the problem in the night. A comparison of a midsummer nights dream and romeo and juliet written by william shakespeare Romeo, they meet and share the balcony scene at night, but the next day, "the day is hot" and "these hot days is the mad blood stirring", and sure enough trouble arrives in the person of Tybalt.

Although Romeo and Juliet find some relief in each other's arms the next night, yet the day must come. This tension is symbolised by the lark representing the day and renewed danger and the nightingale representing the night, safety and consummated love.

Truly we wish with Juliet that "all the world will be in love with night and pay no worship to the garish sun". What is the imagery in A Midsummer Night's Dream?

All of Shakespeare's plays are crammed with imagery. To list it all would take forever. Imagery involving the moon is particularly common in A Midsummer Night's Dream. For exa…mple, "O, methinks how slow this old moon wanes!

She lingers my desires like to a stepdame or a dowager long withering out a young man's revenue. Or another example, "Then the moon like to a silver bow new-bent in heaven shall behold the night of our solemnities" That's also personification and simile. And that's only the first two lines of the play!