Essays academic service


Comparing and contrasting aldous huxleys a brave new world and george orwells 1984

Kaitlin Oglesby This lesson compares two classic examples of dystopian novels: Aldous Huxley's ''Brave New World'' and George Orwell's ''1984'' and shows how in each novel, the population is controlled by the government, be it by unfettered pleasure or by censorship and fear.

Dystopias Written less than two decades apart, Brave New World and 1984 present very different views about what a runaway technocratic future would look like. They both reflect their author's vision of what a dystopia might look like.

1984 vs. Brave New World: Comparison

A dystopia can be thought of as a society that is designed as a utopia, but functions as the opposite i. In both of these novels, many of the social designs we hold most dear are abolished. The concept of family as we know it is largely greeted with abhorrence. Instead, social institutions revolve largely around the state. Additionally, societies have perhaps become too dependent on what advanced technology has to offer.

  • Lenina Crowne's behaviour in remaining faithful to one man at a time and her aberrant interest in Bernard Marx dismays her friend Fanny, who encourages her back towards a 'normal' promiscuity;
  • The Savage attempts to create a world for himself taking his own problems into it, of course, but escaping as far as he is able from the society into which he cannot fit , but his privacy is invaded and a 'feelie' is made of his life;
  • See someone you think is attractive?
  • There seems to be a similarity of attitude between Orwell and Huxley which incorporates a kind of contempt for 'ordinary people', who do not have high aspirations or deep perception, though Orwell at least grants them potential;
  • While we as a society try to keep sex behind closed doors, Brave New World uses consequence-free coitus to control the masses;
  • With this granted to him, his rebellion evaporates in an instant and he has conformed.

In any event, a central theme in both works is the importance of control. In both books, a key method of control is caste.

Expert Answers

However, there's a catch. There are five major castes in Brave New World, with people conditioned from birth to feel that they can be happy only in their own castes. A Beta, the second-highest caste, may feel that Alphas have to think too hard to have fun, while Gammas have to work too hard. Meanwhile, caste in 1984 is dependent on one's position in the Party. The uninformed masses outside the Party, the Proles, are free to live lives that are little better than those of drones.

Module Five

Meanwhile, Outer Party members are constantly pitted against what the reader would consider to be normal behavior in hopes of gaining access to the luxurious life of the Inner Party. Of course, that opportunity at life in the Inner Party never happens. That's a pretty strong statement, but there is an overwhelming emphasis on sources of pleasure that are largely considered taboo in today's society. See someone you think is attractive?

  1. The rejection of history takes a more aggressive form in 1984, where it becomes impossible to understand the past, because the details of the past are constantly rewritten to conform with the requirements of the present. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.
  2. Each person is kept in a state of persecuted fear, and distrust of those around him—who ought to be the 'nearest and dearest' but may well turn out to be betrayers.
  3. The lower castes do not really have any influence in Huxley's book, and are simply the background to the doings of the upper-caste characters.
  4. In Huxley's World State, human interaction is simply reduced to the shallowest possible level, so that feelings become unimportant because they are trivial.
  5. Only John, with the aid of the wisdom of Shakespeare , has the heroic essence that is capable of rebelling. Just as history is effectively abolished in both societies, so is the family.

Forget our society's rules about modesty and consent, you can sleep with whomever you want. In fact, you'd be considered weird to not want to sleep with just about everyone.

While we as a society try to keep sex behind closed doors, Brave New World uses consequence-free coitus to control the masses. But what if you're just having a bad day? The answer is simple: Having a really bad one? While we still debate heavily the merits of recreational drugs, Brave New World readily accepts their place as a control mechanism. After all, a soma a day keeps the revolt away.