Essays academic service


Drunkenness as a social problem in crime and punishment a novel by fyodor dostoevsky

And yet, despite this overwhelming evidence that rational choice plays little to no part in political decision-making, those who advocate for liberal causes continue to build arguments around logic, facts, statistics, and science, rather than reckoning with the seemingly impenetrable potency of emotions like hate, shame, and fear that lead people to make unreasonable choices and form baseless opinions about one another.

Reading Crime and Punishment in 2018, we are reminded of the need to take irrationality and willful self-destruction seriously.

  • A later novel, The Possessed, was inspired by a court case where a group of nihilists were put on trial for murdering a member of their organization;
  • Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia defines dualism as:

They are not only born out of individual choice; they are social forces that can play a much larger role in our politics than we might care to admit. Severe overcrowding and limited opportunities for employment left many in a state of desperation.

Re-reading Crime and Punishment: the Drunkards

Drunkenness, prostitution, disease, unemployment, family breakups, and abandoned children all came to typify the nature of Russian reality in the 1860s. Petersburg, but it takes special care to castigate those eager to exploit the victims of these desperate circumstances most notably the pawnbroker, Alyona Ivanovna. Indeed, an onslaught of everyday economic violence the denial of loans, the shame and humiliation inflicted on those in debt, the indignity of having to beg, and so forth forms so painful a backdrop that the murder sometimes gets lost in the larger canvas of depravity that Dostoyevsky paints in Crime and Punishment.

He has just completed a trial run of the murder, visiting the pawnbroker and taking note of her apartment, its layout, her habits. His daughter Sonya works as a prostitute to support the family.

Drunkenness as a social problem in crime and punishment a novel by fyodor dostoevsky

Ultimately, though, Dostoyevsky was concerned not with debasing any single idea, but rather with exposing how easy it is to use lofty theories to mask self-interest, and how quickly mere concepts—unlike convictions—could shift and evolve. Some two years earlier, he had become involved in an intellectual society devoted to the utopian ideals of the socialist Charles Fourier. Dostoyevsky was drawn to the group, known as the Petrashevsky Circle, largely for the principled stance it took against the institution of serfdom.

A later novel, The Possessed, was inspired by a court case where a group of nihilists were put on trial for murdering a member of their organization. He conversed with lawyers about the nature of guilt and innocence and debated court decisions in one of the journals he edited, Diary of a Writer.

In depicting the taking of a human life, Dostoyevsky could bring the full spectrum of lived experience rapidly into focus. At least this is what he claims.

Follow The Nation

Indeed, with Crime and Punishment, Dostoyevsky rewrote a basic facet of the detective story by eliminating the question of who committed the crime and focusing instead on the matter of why. Was it a utilitarian act of selflessness, eliminating a greedy and tyrannical individual for the greater good?

  1. Making readers wait for the next move of a mysterious character is a classic device to heighten suspense. The polarized themes of reason and unreason, faith and unbelief, moral freedom and moral slavery, frame the tension of modern man, a tension which finds a precarious resolution in the vision of Christ, Dostoevsky s moral-aesthetic ideal.
  2. Sonia immediately forgives him when he confesses his crime and in general refuses to judge or condemn other human beings. Drunkenness, prostitution, disease, unemployment, family breakups, and abandoned children all came to typify the nature of Russian reality in the 1860s.
  3. This is the moment when we ought to feel the most compassion for her, but the possibility of a positive response is severely undermined.

Or did he just want revenge against one of the many people in St. There is no order or rationale to human behavior.

Crime and Punishment

Decades earlier, Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky still in the early stages of building their translation dynasty brought their talents to Crime and Punishment, producing a rendition unmistakably theirs: In fact, the decision had been made earlier, but only announced to the prisoners at the very last minute.

The text has been corrected. To submit a correction for our consideration, click here. For Reprints and Permissions, click here.