Essays academic service

A comparison of zeferelli and luhramnn versions of the movie romeo and juliet

Hire Writer An example of this is the language of this play, which is old English Shakespearean. Also, another aspect that comes from the time the play was made was the clothing, which is exactly as the styles were in the Middle Ages. And a third example is the use of swords in the battle. The Zeferelli version of Romeo and Juliet was very similar to the play, because the dress, language, and weaponry were all the same.

How do I compare Baz Luhrmann's and Franco Zeffirelli's versions of Romoe and Juliet?

The only major difference between these two versions was the interpretation of a few events, such as the battle between Tybalt and Mercutio. In this battle, Tybalt was seen as merely fooling around, instead of in an angry rage as the play displayed.

  1. This can be seen especially in Act one Scene five, in which Romeo and Juliet meet for the first time.
  2. Secondly, in the play, Tybalt returns to Romeo rather than Romeo running after him as he does in both films.
  3. Zeffirelli starts the balcony scene with Romeo gazing longingly at Juliet who is on her balcony dreamily staring across her garden. The dramatic change between the two styles of fighting is significant.

Even though the Luhrman version of Romeo and Juliet had essentially the same lines and storyline as the play, although a few lines were edited out, and there were many other substantial differences. First, this movie was set during the modern day, with everything except the language modernised and has the MTV generation feel to it.

Next, the movie was about two major gangs battling against on another, while the play focused around two relatively normal aristocratic families from their time. Also, another difference between the two versions is the weaponry. In A West Side Story, two gangs are feuding during modern times. Both gangs are fighting over a piece of territory. Also, two people from separate gangs fall in love, and one of them dies.

Romeo and Juliet – Zeffirelli and Luhrmann Essay

Each of these events occurs in Romeo and Juliet in at least one of the versions, demonstrating the incredible similarity between these stories. Although they were all quite similar, each was unique in at least one way. The Zeferelli version showed the battle between Tybalt and Mercutio as friendly, unlike the other versions. Two examples of uniqueness in A West Side Story were that one of the two lovers survived, and the feud was between white Americans and Puerto Ricans.

The original play was unique due to the fact that this was the first version upon which all other versions were based. The Luhrman version was unique due to the fact that this movie was the most modern and fast paced of all the stories, and is the one that related to us the most closely due to how modern the storyline was.

The original themes in each of these both similar but terrific stories are comparable, although varied enough to make each one valuable.

How to cite this page Choose cite format: