Essays academic service


To what extent is eddie carbone the tragic hero

Whether such ordinary characters should be permitted a title so long associated with nobility is subject to debate.

Is Eddie Carbone a tragic hero?

However, with Carbone conforming to every other characteristic of the tragic hero, this discrepancy may be forgivable, or perhaps even welcome in our modern times. We go on to witness the reverence with which Carbone is regarded in his own home, as niece Catherine greets him excitedly before seeking his opinion on her new skirt.

Eddie Carbone As A Tragic Hero In A View From The Bridge

Not only is Carbone loved by his family, he is also a respected figure within the Red Hook community, for his adherence to its Italian values. His narration rarely strays from Carbone and only incorporates other characters on the basis of their relationship with him. A cardinal function of the Greek Chorus is to bridge a connection between the audience and the protagonist; the tragic hero must be one with whom we can relate, as Aristotle said.

After all, our ability to relate to prestigious tragic heroes is limited by their rank and situation; only their inescapable humanity enables us to identify with their plight. Vital to the tragic hero is their fall.

Chat forums

And one cannot deny the thoroughness with which A View from the Bridge skins Carbone of his glory. He is pathetic- a fact enhanced by the symbolic stage directions, whereby his former sponsors gradually abandon him: Yet there is still a point of contention: Nevertheless, in any fall from grace, it is those closest to the subject of defamation that are most important: Thus, whilst traditional heroes may experience dishonour on a grander scale, the likes of Carbone provoke just as great an audience reaction.

Hamatria is also intrinsic to the tragic hero: Were he to acknowledge his perverse desires, it is possible that Carbone could prevent his downfall: This concept is captured in the symbolism of Carbone dying, literally by his own hand: In this respect, therefore, Carbone is just as fitted to the role of the tragic hero as any Shakespearean conception.

  1. However, with Carbone conforming to every other characteristic of the tragic hero, this discrepancy may be forgivable, or perhaps even welcome in our modern times. Though very unusual for a Drama to start off with introductions by a narrator.
  2. Many plays throughout history have attempted realism but not many have been able to captivate an audience well enough for it to be recognised. His narration rarely strays from Carbone and only incorporates other characters on the basis of their relationship with him.
  3. He is quite a large man. In his plays he explores the struggles of the ordinary man against authority and insurmountable odds.
  4. Not only is Carbone loved by his family, he is also a respected figure within the Red Hook community, for his adherence to its Italian values.

Of course, this is essential to the tragic hero, for there is no tragedy in chance misfortune: It is plain, therefore, that Eddie Carbone epitomises the tragic hero in all but rank.

Yet this seems to matter little: When aiming to create a microcosm of society, contemporary writers are now inclined to use ordinary characters, as opposed to royalty.

  • She tries to prevent the inevitable from happening by getting Catherine to?
  • He invites Rodolfo, in a game-fight;
  • A View From The Bridge is a play written by Arthur Miller in 1955, which was originally arranged in rhymes but later was changed.

Thus it seems that, whilst Oedipus may have thrived in Ancient Greece, Carbone is of far greater relevance today: If theatre is to retain a high level of significance within our world, the rules of tragedy must be regarded as flexible. And Miller seems to agree, slipping Alfieri the ambiguous line: