Essays academic service

Negative symptoms for john nash in beautiful minds

But did he really have schizophrenia?

  1. Actual acts of violence are generally accepted indicating a moderately increased number of violent acts by a minority of individuals who are diagnosed with Schizophrenia.
  2. Schizophrenia is usually diagnosed in people aged 17-35 years. The field has made virtually no progress in unpacking chronic severe illness and differentiating out several distinct entities.
  3. But the film demonstrates this type of therapy when Nash is admired to the hospital.
  4. As for the medications, the textbook, and the movie state that medications are crucial to reduce the symptoms of schizophrenia, and that the medications have side effects.
  5. After being released from the psychiatric hospital, John tried to resume his normal life and his mathematical research.

Core schizophrenia begins in adolescence or early adulthood, may involve a psychotic break, certainly involves diminished executive function, affective blunting and a thought disorder. It does not necessarily mean the hallucinations and delusions of psychosis. Now, what symptoms did Nash seem to have? His illness began in 1959 at age 30, a bit past the typical window. He had already fashioned his brilliant doctoral dissertation.

Did John Nash’s schizophrenia boost his ‘beautiful mind’?

But 1959 was probably the very worst time in the history of American psychiatry to become ill. Transference means coming to see your therapist as your parent.

Nash was certainly delusional and evidently hallucinated as well. He filled the blackboards of Fine Hall at Princeton with indecipherable scribblings, and wandered about the campus in an apparent daze. Whatever it was that had seized his brain for this decades-long period had apparently lost its grip.

Now, this does not really happen in core adolescent-onset schizophrenia. So this is what gives me the willies about the Nash case, that we may have given him the wrong diagnosis.

Or rather that his psychoanalytically oriented clinicians in 1959 gave him the wrong diagnosis and ever since this has been unthinkingly accepted. This is the way psychiatry often works.

A Beautiful Mind: Analyzing How Schizophrenia is Portrayed in Movies versus Reality

The field has made virtually no progress in unpacking chronic severe illness and differentiating out several distinct entities. In no other field of medicine would this be conceivable!

In 1957 East German psychiatrist Karl Leonhard proposed a complicated alternative to the Kraepelin-Bleulerian standard that still has some acolytes today. Nash has now passed on. Some have to stay on meds, others don't. These are not all the same illness!